County Planning Chairman: "Hands Tied Without Zoning"

Fairhope, Alabama 

 

August 2024 meeting.

 

BIG BARNWELL HOUSING PROJECT OK'D 

After hearing objections from some district residents worried about density, traffic, drainage, water/sewer availability, fire/police service, and quality of life issues -- the Baldwin County planning commission approved Saddlebrook, a 339 lot subdivision at the nothwest corner of the Hwy 98/CR 24 intersection in the west-Barnwell area (about four miles south of Fairhope).

In answer to the complaints, the project's engineer said infrastructure improvements planned should actually make drainage better in the area (up to a 100 year flood), and the developer would be upgrading existing city of Fairhope water/sewer main capacity to the project.

All state and county traffic requirements will have to be met as well, he added. 

One change already made was the elimination of access from CR 24, responding to resident's complaints. 

NO ZONING THE PROBLEM?

Chairman Steven Pumphrey told the crowd the commission's "hands were tied" without zoning: if all "boxes are checked" and subdivision regulations on the books are met, there is no legal way to deny such applications.

Residents of the planning district (17) voted against enacting zoning about two years ago, by just 23 votes; there could be a renewed effort coming, the Times has learned.

TWO EARLIER DENIALS

Earlier in the meeting the commission recommended denying two rezoning requests (higher density)  in other districts already with zoning, on grounds of incompatibility with surrounding property.  Final decisions on those rest with the county commission though.


Salldebrook approved.


Comments

Anonymous said…
Baldwin county needs to start thinking abouta professional fire department.
Anonymous said…
Bull
Anonymous said…
Better late than never they say.
Anonymous said…
Some people do not want someone to dictate what is built or done in their area. Well this is the flip side of what will occur. It will be a FREE FOR ALL. People wake up! This area cannot accommodate the present population much less hundreds more to come. Zoning may be what you need and people making the decisions need to consider infrastructure.
Anonymous said…
Not everyone’s hands are tied. They have to get water,power, sewer, roads, and classrooms somewhere. Why not implement moratoriums until governments can catch up?
Publisher said…
There IS a moratorium on NEW sewer service in this area by the Fairhope city council; but this project's application was about a month before it was enacted.
Anonymous said…
Stating that these were approved before the moratorium ….is no excuse!! Was there NO ONE LOOKING AT WHAT HAD BEEN APPROVED AND LOOKING AT THE NUMBERS AND FIGURED ON WHAT WOULD BE NEEDED IN INFRASTRUCTURE ??? This is ….NOT MY FAULT SYNDROME!!!!
Anonymous said…
Could Indian burial sites be on the property
Anonymous said…
Just slow walk the hooks up forever
Anonymous said…
Chamber of commerce and realtor's association wants to shoe horn as many people in as they can. Good for business.
Anonymous said…
Yes and if you have Real Estate people serving on those boards of city and county then that is part of the problem!!! Wake up people!!!
Anonymous said…
People, you live in a Democratic nation. You live in a Capitalistic nation. You live in a conservative state.
All of this is by design, in our constitution and you choose to live here.
You can never lock the doors and prevent others from moving here.
But you can choose to move out if you’re so miserable.
Anonymous said…
I spotted an Eagle nest right next to the Indian burial ground. It has to be as all those arrow heads laying in the grass :)
Anonymous said…
Better get u some zoning there asap!
Anonymous said…
“Don’t Tread On Me” with runaway growth! Many of us moved here when things were smaller and preferred to keep it that way.
Anonymous said…
Too bad about that. We live in a country where people still have there property rights! If we want to build thousands of houses on it, ok to do so! Thank God.
Anonymous said…
If building thousands of houses only affected an individual property owner, that would be great. Unfortunately, other property owners are affected by traffic jams, crowded schools, polluted waterways, etc. This violates our rights and no, we should not have to move.
Farmers have the right to sell, but it should be for ag purposes only. If necessary, they should be helped out by the government.
We don’t want to be dependent on foreign countries for our produce.
We are a throw away society and have plenty of vacant retail. Why do we need new buildings?
I am hoping every citizen exercises their constitutional right and vote out any local official that had a hand in this mess being created.
Anonymous said…
What about the rezoning they just approved across from JL Newton in district 39 where there iIS zoning???? Their hands tied for that too??
Anonymous said…
The planning commission did not approve the rezoning across from the Newton School. In fact they denied it. The county commission has the final say so in rezoning.
Anonymous said…
Sure. Let us vote out people who stand up for people's private property rights! Become like Russia and China!
Anonymous said…
To "This violates our rights and no, we should not have to move"
Than take it to court and see how far your perceived rights gets you.
As far as moving that is your choice, isn't living in a free country wonderful!
Anonymous said…

As a previous post noted...
Some people do not want someone to dictate what is built or done in their area. Well this is the flip side of what will occur
That said the issue will be fire and police protection,the city of Fairhope provides NO EMERGENCY SERVICES AT ALL.Fire is volunteer and ambulance is contracted.SO as the city funds tunnels,parks and purchases out side the necessary it's everyone for them selves.
Anonymous said…
City provides no emergency services? What about police? Firemen are mostly volunteers ... but who buys the equipment? that's right city tax payers. Millions every year!