Recycling Program In Disarray

Fairhope, Alabama

MAYOR CALLS IT "A MESS"

Because of dwindling public participation, reduced market-ablilty for recyclables,  and other problems, Mayor Kant told a city council work session its time to make some "hard decisions" about the city's recycling program.

Kant: "Are we going to be in the recycling business ... or not ... ?"

"The second question  ... is how?"

Kant said that to prepare next year's budget he needs some direction from the council and Recycling Committee about how to proceed: either continue sorting at the curb or to switch to co-mingling -- where recyclables are mixed together in one container instead, and sorted out later.

Kant: "We need some direction ... its a mess right now ... how we're trying to deal with it."

Recycling Committee member Councilman Ford agreed: "It is a mess ... before ... we separated at curbside ... but people see a garbage truck come by ... and everything thrown into that ... ."

Ford said Fairhope has fallen behind other cities (in recycling) where "we led the way before."

EQUIPMENT FAILURES BLAMED

Kant said complaints  are coming in from citizens who go to all the trouble to separate their items, only to see city workers dump them all into the same container on the pick-up truck.

Public Works Director Fidler said recycling items have to be mixed together sometimes now because of equipment failures: the recycling truck has to be used elsewhere because of garbage truck breakdowns and other manpower issues.

Fidler: "Every time we turn around one of the new garbage trucks is breaking down ... we can't separate ... don't have enough trucks ...  with the manpower ... to separate."

Fidler said the co-mingled recyclables are then taken to a recycling plant in Loxley -- and sold at a greatly reduced rate (compared to if they had already been separated).

TO CO-MINGLE OR NOT?

The Recycling Committee is to meet to study the facts to make a recommendation whether to continue requiring citizens to separate their items at the curb or switch officially to the easier-for-citizens but less profitable co-mingling method.

Mayor Kant said it would be brought up for consideration at an upcoming strategic planning meeting as well.

Kant: "We put off buying equipment for four years because we didn't know if we were going to be in the sanitation business or not ... ."

Back in 2009, the city was planning to participate in Baldwin County's proposed Team Green single stream recycling; but that idea died when the company went bankrupt (click).

MORE COMMITTEE MEMBERS NEEDED

Applications are still being solicited for the Recycling Committee which will be studying the issue.

They may be obtained from the city clerk's office (click).

Ford: "I don't know how we got in the shape we're in ... but we've got a lot of recovery ... examination to do ... ."


Comments

Anonymous said…
Separating recyclables isn't the least bit difficult. And anyone who is actually going to do the responsible thing and participate in the recycling program will also be perfectly happy to do it. I've done it for 11 years, with no hardship whatsoever. But it has ticked me off lately to see it all piled into the back of a single compartment garbage truck!
Anonymous said…
The most important issue is that everyone needs to get on board and be a contributing member of the recycling process; it's another form of good stewardship!! And, because we are blessed to live in Fairhope and have curbside recycling, we should all be more conscientious about helping reduce the pounds going to landfills. Until the city has upgraded the trucks to facilitate keeping items seperated, I will deliver my recycle things to the Municipal drop-off so the city can get the higher return $$-wise.
Anonymous said…
I love that our town has curb recycling and will do whatever is necessary to keep it going.
Anonymous said…
I'd like to see the city "incentivize" this a little - encourage more people to recycle and compost by charging by volume or weight, or both, for garbage pickup. If they did that, my bill for garbage pickup would be half what my neighbors' bills are. And if there were less garbage, the city could revisit the idea of once a week pickup, saving quite a bit of money.
Anonymous said…
Sounds like a poor maintenance issue if the new trucks are breaking down.....
Anonymous said…
I'll say it's a mess! I recently moved from a more rural location into town. One of the things I was looking forward to was the recycling program. I went to City Hall, paid my utility deposit and went home, expecting SOME kind of info to follow. (I didn't think to ask at the time.) When I got home, I found that there is a trash can here. But, I don't have recycling bins. Do I need to buy them? When is recycling pick up in my area? What things are recyclable? How do I know?

One of these days I will get back across town with enough time to find all that out, but you can't really expect people to participate this way. If I hadn't already known there was a program, I wouldn't know to ask. How many more like me don't know to ask at all?
Anonymous said…
WOW.....Fidler just bought new trucks and they are breaking down. Kant used to be Public Works Director and he does not know how to fix it? They just bought that big new empty building....sounds like new management is needed in the Public Works Department. But if the flowers are pretty....happy...happy...happy...
Anonymous said…
I thought the Mayor was in charge....he should step up and fix it and fix the problems in Public Works..
Anonymous said…
What kind of lazy, selfish Fairhope resident doesn't recycle????
Anonymous said…
The last city council got this all fouled up> I hope the new group will be able to get it straightened out.
Anonymous said…
Maybe you should blame it on George Bush too. Give her new trucks and she still can't get it right.....With all the Mayor's experience and his hand picked (we met at the funeral home council)why can't Kant figure it out...because Kant Can't.
Anonymous said…
Get Fidler, Kant, Sullivan, Ford and Lisa Hanks in the same room and they can figure out anything. But we will have to wait until Kant gets back from Europe to fix it.
Anonymous said…
Didn't someone fall off the recycle area and die? Tear up trucks, death, wow and the Public Works Director still has a Job? WOW......but as long as the flowers are pretty....happy....happy....happy. As I continue to ride on the back of this trash truck with no dental insurance. I hope Kant enjoys his trip to Europe while we employees do without and my boss lady tears stuff up.
Anonymous said…
Recycling is for the liberal tree huggers. This is Alabama you know.
Anonymous said…
This thing has always been mismanaged. Mend it or end it.