Old House To Become Mexican Restaurant?

Fairhope, Alabama


309 Ingleside Avenue


ca. 1940's

REZONING REQUESTED

What many consider a historic house located on 1.6 acres at 309 Ingleside Avenue (at Nichols) could become a Mexican cuisine restaurant if the city council approves a zoning change requested by its owner.

Rosetta Lewis Wasp and Mildred Brown are requesting a zoning change from R-2 to B-3B to allow for its sale to potential new owner Chris Cullen ... who says he plans to convert existing structures to a restaurant.

They are descendants of John and Nancy Lewis. A historical marker was erected earlier this year near the site of their original homestead on Bancroft Street downtown:

"Nancy Lewis, a widowed ex-Slave sold her homestead in 1895 to the Fairhope Industrial Association. Her acreage was a part of two-hundred acres bought by the Fairhope Founders and Mrs. Lewis having paid taxes on her homestead for many years and proving ownership, became a contributor to the settlement of the Single Tax experiment on the Bluff. She used $4.58 of that payment to buy forty acres where Thomas Hospital stands today."



IN HOSPITAL OVERLAY DISTRICT

The property is located in the city's Medical Overly District, with two restaurants already operating nearby ('The Warehouse' and 'District Hall') ... as well as numerous M-1, industrial-type businesses (public storage, AC repair, etc.).

Cullen currently operates the El Barrio Restaurante in Birmingham (click) and wants to open a second location and move his family here; his wife is a Fairhope native.

If approved, the renovation will include adding a commercial kitchen to the house as well as restrooms and parking; sidewalks will be installed along streets and plant buffers along property lines.

If approved by the city council, construction is expected begin in spring of 2020.

(Plans were announced last year to convert the historic Church Street Inn to a restaurant as well, but that project has not begun.)



site plans











an

Comments

Anonymous said…
Thank you, Mr. Cullen. Sounds like a great idea and wonderful addition to the Fairhope restaurant scene.
Anonymous said…
Should be soul food or barbecue maybe instead.
Folly Finder said…
"Should be soul food or barbecue maybe instead."

Good idea. Buy a building, remodel it, plan the menu, hire staff, and open your own.
Anonymous said…
Great place for a new restaurant and everyone loves fresh Mexican food!
Anonymous said…
It’s great to hear someone wanting to renovate an old house instead of tearing it down, as is going on all over the City. Keep the old houses that can be preserved!
Giorgi said…
So many restaurants are struggling in Fairhope, I wish them well
Anonymous said…
Giorgi, are there really any restaurants that aren't doing well in Fairhope? It appears to me that every place is slammed for lunch and dinner almost always. If there are good places to eat, perhaps they aren't on the 'beaten path' and need to get the word out that they would appreciate customers trying them out.
Anonymous said…
Every Mexican restaurant I have been to is nasty. The food has been frozen and simply nasty. They seem to pop up on every corner everywhere you go and all the same. Dirty too. My experience. No thanks , I’ll pass
Bamastratus said…
Poeple let me inform you all.
I live in Birmingham and my inlaws live in Fairhope.
We have an el barrio in birmingham an I assure you it is one of if not the BEST restaurant in the city.
Fairhope is lucky to be getting this addition to the city. This is true authentic Mexican restaurant with the freshest locally sourced ingredients. They rotate the menu seasonally as well.
This is a restaurant you should support!!!
This is as far from your everyday Mexican as you can get.
Hope this helps.