Councilman Questions Golf Course Closure

Fairhope, Alabama

Updated.




CORONAVIRUS STATE OF EMERGENCY

Councilman Burrell is questioning the closure of the Quail Creek golf course because that was never authorized by the city council.

The council's March 23rd emergency resolution closed (until further notice) only:

* parks with childrens' playground equipment
* dog park
* pier and north beach


Golf courses were allowed to remain open under certain conditions in the governor's subsequent stay-at-home/business closure order; but at the discretion of local authorities.



"ABUNDANCE OF CAUTION" THE REASON

 Mayor Wilson justified the decision to close the course and other parks:

“My decision to close all parks was out of an abundance of precaution both for City employees and our citizens. Based on the data being shared with our local government, the State of Alabama has yet to reach its peak for confirmed cases and deaths. Based on this, I would not support reopening until we see a healthy decline. Council has always had the ability to reverse this decision which I made two weeks ago. The Azalea City Golf course in Mobile closed over a week before ours. We do not have the manpower to monitor a large course and it was opened exclusively to members before it was closed. During this time, it became evident that players were not adhering to social distancing among other concerns. I believe the more proactive we are as a community; we will help flatten the curve in addition to getting us back to “normal” sooner. Other courses have made different decisions for which we all will be affected, unfortunately.”

She made additional comments on her Facebook page later-(click). 


Councilman Burrell responded later: 

The fact is the City Council passed a resolution that specifically called for the course to remain open.  The Mayor has no authority to close it.  Why would Council need to take action to reopen it, when we already took very specific action for it to remain open?  That action was ignored.  One of the Mayor’s duties is to execute the council’s resolve, which includes the action taken to keep the course open.  I sent the Mayor an email on April 9th urging her to abide by the Council’s resolution and open the course.  In that email, I pointed out that we never agreed to any, nor took any action to close the course.  We understand there were Quail Creek employees with concerns over working, and we respect that, but we can find people to temporarily work at the course, and there are dozens of ways to mitigate the risks to employees and golfers, many of which are being used by other local golf courses.



EMPLOYEE HEALTH ONE CONCERN

The Times received a message about three weeks ago from the family of a clubhouse employee who  were concerned their older relative was being "forced to work" ... and be exposed to the virus there. Shortly afterwards the course was closed.

The epidemic in Alabama is expected to peak on about April 20th






 

Comments

Anonymous said…
I guess stay home really means until you want to go somewhere.
Anonymous said…
Spring golf fever is worse than any virus.
Ty Web said…
Culling the herd of golfers would raise our collective I.Q.

Just sayin'.
Anonymous said…
if we had a city manager and the mayor became a voting member of the council again there would not be problems like these anymore.
Anonymous said…
I don’ play. But the situation intrigued me so I carefully read the State Health orders. They make blanket statements and then list exemptions which seemingly contradict the blanket statement. Logically I think you could play golf and follow the distancing and shared equipment protocols (don’t let two from different households share a cart). According to the Governor you can play golf and the CC specifically said keep the course open , so the Mayor is being insubordinate. I think it is a silly issue to take a stand on if that is what she is doing. It would be interesting to know if the mayor discussed closing the course with any of the CC or did she just do it. Sounds like the latter..

Anonymous said…
A wise decision to keep the course closed. All we need are golfers getting sick and then spreading to other people.
Anonymous said…
Early on there was much unknown even outright denial. The thanks belongs in China not an elected public officer. That has changed, while still argument on how to proceed. But our and my Constitution is not up for debate.