Too Much Commercial Activity In City Parks?

Fairhope, Alabama

Update: Terms of a federal/state grant (2007) prohibits use of south beach park for other than recreational activities.


'Maker's Market' earlier this year.

NO ROOM FOR CITIZENS?

During its last work session, Community Affairs Director Crawford sought direction from the city council about reducing commercial and other excessive reserved-space events in city parks.

Crawford said she has been getting complaints about "too much stuff going on ... preventing citizens from enjoying their parks" with peaceful activities like dog-walking.

Crawford: "Do we want them open to the public ... or rented constantly." She also observed that the parklands involved were deeded to the city by the Single Tax Corp. in the 1930s for citizens' use/enjoyment.

Ordinance 1575 (see below) restricts rental activities to three park-areas only: the beach pavilion, Henry George, and South Beach; only individuals or non-profits may rent for performing arts, weddings (parties, memorials) or designated "festivals."

Possible amendments mentioned by Crawford include limiting applicants to two events per year and specifically prohibiting sub-leasing. Higher rental fees for non-citizens is being discussed too.

Councilman Martin and Burrell agreed about the no sub-leasing restriction amendment. 

Martin: "Should definitely be no sub-leasing .... our fees low ... people making money off our public facilities."

Burrell suggested different fees for different parks may be in order too, due to size/space differences.

Councilman Robinson agreed the ordinance needed "cleaning up" -- but said he needed more time to think about just how.

Conyers said "parks should be available to citizens of Fairhope first."

Crawford was to incorporate suggestions into a draft ordinance-amendment for council to look at -- as a first step.

MAYOR WEIGHS IN LATER

Mayor Sullivan was not present for this council discussion but commented later: "The park rental was never supposed to allow renters to sublease or make a profit off the parks. Also, we are hopeful that we will begin the waterfront project soon." 

South Beach Park will be entirely-closed for renovations later this year.


Current  Ordinance.


Comments

Anonymous said…
Why is an admission charge not being collocated to enter the pavilion beach this year ?
Anonymous said…
OMG...It's time to vote these people out. This is about the makers market which is a huge asset to the city. Its every other Sunday 10-3. It's not a burden on the citizens. Get rid of this mayor and council!
Anonymous said…
Thank you Jesus for giving us our parks back!
Anonymous said…
I heard the Blind Tiger guy did not like competition down there.
Anonymous said…
The Fairhope "farmers" market makes a profit and is in a parking lot of a city facility. Actually one of the worst markets for a City that is promoted for its southern charm and beauty.
This work session was one sided with a coordinator who didn't tell the whole story about what the community thinks.
Anonymous said…
As a park is concerned it is a public use parcel,however.The closing of street for Art Walk in which local artists as well as buskers are not allowed on city property.Yes the shops pay a large rent to be there,but once a month during the summer in some areas should be allows ,especially with licensed vendors.Setting limits on the park use is necessary to a point.I find it sad we can't hike or walk in the duck pond area early any more many areas are gone or closed off.However until the city spend their funding a little better the discussion will continue.
Anonymous said…
I thought Jesus sent the tornado to keep the gay people away?
Anonymous said…
Have to protect downtown businesses. Flea Market is hurting them. Subsidized by the city.
Anonymous said…
Sunday Markets have become very popular nationally and are often promoted by the tourism businesses. It’s considered an asset. I hope they can find a favorable place to re-locate.
Anonymous said…
Once again the council is way out of line . Please fixate restrooms at the boat launch
Anonymous said…
I’m more worried about how the city is going to ruin south beach with its “improvement plan.” Seems to me they are probably using the excuse of the mild tornado damage as a way in to finally complete the fed money plan that no citizens seem to want, but each mayor and council seem to insist upon. Please correct me if I’m wrong on the changes that they intend to make
Anonymous said…
Going to fix the collapsing sea wall there and add another restroom if thats what you call ruining.
Anonymous said…
How on earth could the makers market hurt the downtown businesses?? Half of those downtown businesses are closed on Sunday!!
Anonymous said…
If that’s all they are doing, that would be great. There was at one time a plan in place to do much, much more.
Anonymous said…
hurts "only" half the businesses then ... there was a MM on Saturdays too fyi ...
Anonymous said…
The Sunday market isn't a flea market. It is for artists, makers and growers. The Saturday market is a separate thing. The Sunday Maker's Market has been successful for three years, and only now there is a problem? One wonders why. I can't imagine there is competition with any downtown businesses that are actually open on Sundays because the products are pretty different. Just a Fairhope native's opinion...
Anonymous said…
parks should not be rented to anyone!
Anonymous said…
Way too much!
Anonymous said…
breakdown of the rule of law here
Anonymous said…
Wow. Seriously? What, did a little old lady complain that she couldn’t walk her dog because there were (gasp) PEOPLE down by the water? Get a grip. This sounds like an article from the Fairhope Inquisitor, except it’s for real!
Maybe instead of letting a few grumpy loud people control what we do, try taking some polls and see if the majority of people care if there are events held by the water. It’s a nice thing to offer the community and there is the beach walk just down the road if someone really wants to walk their dog where there are no people. SHEESH
Anonymous said…
Against federal law to hold commercial events there. read the big sign posted there for years, if you can ...